Abstract
Key concepts in enterprise architecture include concerns, principles, models, views, and frameworks. While most of these concepts have received ample attention in research, the concept of principles has not been studied much yet. In this article, we therefore specifically focus on the role of principles in the field of enterprise architecture, where we position enterprise architecture as a means to direct enterprise transformations. In practice, many different types of architecture principles are used. At the same time, principles are referred to by different names, including architecture principles, design principles, and IT policies. The primary goal of this article is, therefore, to arrive at a conceptual framework to more clearly clarify and position these different types. The article starts with a discussion on enterprise architecture as a means to govern enterprise transformation. This provides a framework to position the different types of principles, and highlight their roles in enterprise transformations.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Prof. dr. H.A. (Erik) Proper is a Senior Research Manager at the Public Research Centre – Henri Tudor in Luxembourg, where he leads the Services-orented Enterprise Engineering research program. He is also a Professor at the Radboud University Nijmegen, The Netherlands, where he heads up the Theories for Enterprise Engineering group.
Danny Greefhorst, MSc. is a Principal Consultant and Director of ArchiXL in Amersfoort, The Netherlands, and acts as an architect and consultant for clients in the financial and public sector. Danny is also responsible for the EA portal Via Nova Architectura (www.via-novaarchitectura. org). He is also a member of the governing board of the architecture department of the Dutch Computer Science Association (Ngi).
REFERENCES
Beer S.: Diagnosing the System for Organizations. Wiley, New York, New York (1985).
Beijer P., De Klerk T.: IT Architecture: Essential Practice for IT Business Solutions. Lulu (2010).
Bouwens S.: DYA Architectuurprincipes – Deel 1: Basics (DYA Architecture Principles – Part 1: Basics). White Paper, Sogeti, The Netherlands (2008). In Dutch.
Buckl S., Ernst A., Lankes J., Matthes F.: Enterprise Architecture Management Pattern Catalog – Version 1. Technical Report TB 0801, Technische Universität München, Garching bei München, Germany (2008).
CSC Index, Inc. & Hammer & Company, Inc.: PRISM: Dispersion and Interconnection: Approaches to Distributed Systems Architecture, Final Report. Technical Report, Cambridge MA (1986).
Davenport T., Hammer M., Metsisto T.: How Executives can Shape their Company‟s Information Systems. Harvard Business Review 67, 130–134 (1989).
Dietz J.: Enterprise Ontology – Theory and Methodology. Springer, Berlin, Germany. ISBN-10: 9783540291695 (2006).
Dietz J.: Architecture – Building Strategy into Design. Netherlands Architecture Forum, Academic Service – SDU, The Hague, The Netherlands. ISBN-13: 9789012580861 (2008). www.naf.nl.
Fehskens L.: Re-Thinking Architecture. In: 20th Enterprise Architecture Practitioners Conference, The Open Group (2008).
Fehskens L.: What the “Architecture” in “Enterprise Architecture” Ought to Mean. In: Open Group Conference Boston, The Open Group (2010).
Fischer C., Winter R., Aier S.: What is an Enterprise Architecture Design Principle? Towards a consolidated definition. In: Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Enterprise Architecture Challenges and Responses, Yonezawa, Japan (2010).
Go A.: Implementing Enterprise Architecture: Action Research at Air France Carge – KLM Cargo. Master‟s thesis, Delft Technical University, Delft, The Netherlands (2006).
Greefhorst D., Proper H., Van den Ham F.: Principes: de hoeksteen voor architectuur – Verslag van een workshop op het Landelijk Architectuur Congres 2007 (Principles: The Cornerstone of Architecture – A report of a workshop held at the Dutch National Architecture Congres 2007). Via Nova Architectura (2007). In Dutch. www.via-nova-architectura.org.
Greefhorst D.: 2. Number 35 in ICT bibliotheek. In: Ervaringen met het opstellen van architectuurprincipes bij een verzekeraar (Experiences with the formulation of architecture principles at an insurance company). Academic Service – SDU, The Hague, The Netherlands, 53–62. ISBN-13: 9789012119511 (2007). In Dutch.
Halpin T., Morgan T.: Information Modeling and Relational Databases. 2nd Edition. Data Management Systems. Morgan Kaufman. ISBN-13: 9780123735683 (2008).
Hevner A., March S., Park J., Ram S. Design Science in Information Systems Research. MIS Quarterly 28 75–106 (2004).
Hoogervorst J.: Enterprise Governance and Enterprise Engineering. Springer, Diemen, The Netherlands (2009).
Iacob M.E., Jonkers H., Lankhorst M., Proper H.: ArchiMate® 1.0 Specification. The Open Group. ISBN-13: 9789087535025 (2009).
Iacob M.E., Jonkers H.: Quantitative Analysis of Service- Oriented Architectures. International Journal of Enterprise Information Systems 3, 42–60 (2007).
ICTU Nederlandse Overheid Referentie Architectuur 2.0 – Samenhang en samenwerking binnen de elektronische overheid (2007). In Dutch. www.ictu.nl.
Johnson P., Ekstedt M.: Enterprise Architecture: Models and Analyses for Information (2007).
Kersten J.: Propositions. Master‟s thesis, Radboud University Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands (2009). In Dutch
Lankhorst M. et al: Enterprise Architecture at Work: Modelling, Communication and Analysis. Springer, Berlin, Germany. ISBN-10: 3540243712 (2005).
Lee C.: Aerospace Logistics Architecture Program: Action Research at Air France Cargo – KLM Cargo. Master‟s thesis, Delft Technical University, Delft, The Netherlands (2006).
Lidwell W., Holden K., Butler J.: Universal Principles of Design. Rockport Publishers, Inc., Massachusetts (2003).
Lindström A.: On the Syntax and Semantics of Architectural Principles. In: Proceedings of the 39th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (2006).
Lindström A.: An Approach for Developing Enterprise-Specific ICT Management Methods – From Architectural Principles to Measures. In: IAMOT 2006 – 15th International Conference on Management of Technology, Beijing, China (2006).
Meriam–Webster: Meriam–Webster Online, Collegiate Dictionary (2003).
Object Management Group (OMG): Business Motivation Model (BMM) Specification. Technical Report dtc/06–08–03, Needham, Massachusetts (2006).
Object Management Group (OMG): Business Process Modeling Notation™ (BPMN™), v1.1 Specification. Document Number: formal/2008-01-17 (2008).
Object Management Group (OMG): UML® 2.0 Superstructure Specification – Final Adopted Specification. Technical Report ptc/03–08–02 (2003).
Op ‘t Land M., Proper H., Waage M., Cloo J., Steghuis C.: Enterprise Architecture – Creating Value by Informed Governance. Springer, Berlin, Germany. ISBN-13: 9783540852315 (2008).
Op ‘t Land M., Proper H.: Impact of Principles on Enterprise Engineering. In O¨Sterle H., Schelp J., Winter R., eds.: Proceedings of the 15th European Conference on Information Systems, University of St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland 1965–1976 (2007).
Proper H., Hoppenbrouwers S., Veldhuijzen van Zanten G.: Communication of Enterprise Architectures. In Lankhorst M., et al.: Enterprise Architecture at Work: Modelling, Communication and Analysis. 67–82. ISBN-10: 3540243712 (2005).
Ramspeck B.: Formulating Principles in an Effective Way. Master‟s thesis, Radboud University Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands (2008).
Richardson G., Jackson B., Dickson G.: A Principles-Based Enterprise Architecture: Lessons from Texaco and Star Enterprise. MIS Quarterly 14 385–403 (1990). www.jstor.org/stable/249787.
Rijsenbrij D., Schekkerman J., Hendrickx H.: Architectuur, besturingsinstrument voor adaptieve organisaties – De rol van architectuur in het besluitvormingsproces en de vormgeving van de informatievoorziening. Lemma, Utrecht, The Netherlands (2002). ISBN-10: 9059310934 (2002). In Dutch.
Rivera R.: Am I Doing Architecture or Design Work? It Professional 9 46–48 (2007).
Systems Decision-Making. Studentlitteratur. ISBN-13: 9789144027524 (2007).
Tapscott D., Caston A.: Paradigm Shift – The New Promise of Information Technology. McGraw–Hill, New York, New York. ASIN 0070628572 (1993).
The Architecture Working Group of the Software Engineering Committee, Standards Department, IEEE: Recommended Practice for Architectural Description of Software Intensive Systems. Technical Report IEEE P1471:2000, ISO/IEC 42010:2007: The Architecture Working Group of the Software Engineering Committee, Standards Department, IEEE, Piscataway, New Jersey. ISBN-10: 0738125180 (2000).
The Engineers‟ Council for Professional Development. Science 94 (1941) 456.
The Open Group: TOGAF® Version 9. Van Haren Publishing, Zaltbommel, The Netherlands. ISBN-13: 9789087532307 (2009).
Van Boekel K.: Architectuurprincipes: Functie en Formulering (Architecture Principles: Function and Formulation). Master‟s thesis, Radboud University Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands (2009). In Dutch.
Van den Tillaart M.: Propositions into a Framework. Master‟s thesis, Radboud University Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands (2009).
Van’t Wout J., Waage M., Hartman H., Stahlecker M., Hofman A.: The Integrated Architecture Framework Explained. Springer, Berlin, Germany. ISBN-13: 9783642115172 (2010).
Wagter R., Van den Berg M., Luijpers J., Van Steenbergen M.: Dynamic Enterprise Architecture: How to Make It Work. Wiley, New York, New York. ISBN-10: 0471682721 (2005).
Zachman J.: A Framework for Information Systems Architecture. IBM Systems Journal 26 (1987).
Journal of Enterprise Architecture