Mohammad Esmaeil Zadeh, Gary Millar, Edward Lewis
In the literature, there are many definitions of Enterprise Architecture (EA), but most of them have three items in common: elements, relationships and principles. Among these, principles represent an essential element in the definition of EA, and some researchers posit that they are the main element in this definition. However, despite the recent advances in defining enterprise architecture principles (EAPs), this notion is suffering from the lack of a theoretical foundation that provides a logical framework for defining them. Stafford Beer’s Viable System Model (VSM) and its application to IT governance, the Viable Governance Model (VGM), have shown to be comprehensive blueprints for designing viable organizations and IT governance arrangements, respectively. Similarly, in recent realizations of EA, the design of the whole organization, and not just the IT, is brought into consideration. Therefore, this paper aims to establish whether the laws and principles of cybernetics, especially those embodied in the VSM and the VGM, can provide a sound theoretical basis for deriving EA principles. This paper investigates the principles defined in the Open Group’s TOGAF based on the theoretical concepts drawn from the VSM/VGM and cybernetics more broadly. This investigation demonstrates that the principles in TOGAF can be derived from the laws and principles of cybernetics.
Enterprise Architecture, Principles, Viable System Model, VSM, Cybernetics
About the authors
Mohammad Esmaeil Zadeh is a PhD student at the University of New South Wales, Australian Defence Force Academy. Mohammad has several years of professional and managerial work experience in the telecommunication and IT sectors. His current area of research investigates the application of viable systems theory to IT governance and Enterprise Architecture.
Gary Millar is a lecturer at the University of New South Wales, Australian Defence Force Academy. His primary research and consultancy work lie in the area of IT Governance. He developed the Viable Governance Model (VGM) which specifies a comprehensive blueprint for establishing governance structures, processes and mechanisms in complex corporations. He has also developed IT strategic plans, formulated IT policies, and managed large IT projects within the government sector.
Edward Lewis is a Senior Lecturer at the University of New South Wales, Australian Defence Force Academy. For 35 years he has been carrying out research and providing consultancy services into strategy and policy planning, Enterprise Architecture, and risk management. He has chaired the Australian and international standards committees that produced ISO/IEC 38500: 2008 Corporate governance of information technology.
S. Aier, C. Fischer, R. Winter: Construction and Evaluation of a Meta-Model for Enterprise Architecture Design Principles, 10th International Conference on Wirtschaftsinformatik, Zurich, Switzerland (2011).
W.R. Ashby: An Introduction to Cybernetics, Chapman & Hall, London (1956).
S. Beer: Brain of the Firm – The Managerial Cybernetics of Organization, Allen Lane and Penguin Press, London (1972).
S. Beer: The Viable System Model: Its Provenance, Development, Methodology, and Pathology, The Journal of the Operational Research Society, Vol. 35, pp.7-25 (1984).
S. Beer: Diagnosing the System for Organizations, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1985).
S. Beer: The Heart of Enterprise, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1984).
B. Boar: Practical Steps for Aligning Information Technology with Business Strategies, New York, John Wiley & Sons (1994).
S. Buckl, F. Matthes, C.M. Schweda: A Viable System Perspective on Enterprise Architecture Management, in SMC 2009, IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, pp.1483-1488 (2009).
FEA: A Practical Guide to the Federal Enterprise Architecture, Version 1.1: www.gao.gov (2001).
T. Graves: The Service-Oriented Enterprise: Enterprise Architecture and Viable Services, Tetradian Books (2009).
D. Greefhorst, E. Proper: Architecture Principles: The Cornerstones of Enterprise Architecture, Springer-Verlag Berlin and Heidelberg GmbH & Co. (2011).
T. Hilder: The Viable System Model, Cavendish Software Ltd. (1995).
A.P. Hoogervorst: Enterprise Governance and Enterprise Engineering, Springer Verlag (2009).
P. Hoverstadt: The Fractal Organization: Creating Sustainable Organizations with the Viable System Model, John Wiley & Sons (2008).
ISO/IEC/IEEE 42010: 2010: Systems and Software Engineering – Architecture Descriptions, International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland.
E. Lewis, G. Millar: The Viable Governance Model: A Theoretical Model for the Corporate Governance of IT, International Journal on IT/Business Alignment and Governance, Vol. 1, pp.19-35 (2010).
E. Lewis: Layrib: Planning Viable Systems: www.layrib.com, cited January 30, 2012.
A. Lindstrom: On the Syntax and Semantics of Architectural Principles, in Proceedings of the 39th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, HICSS ’06, pp.178b-178b (2006).
G. Millar: The Viable Governance Model: A Theoretical Model of IT Governance within a Corporate Setting, DIT Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, University of New South Wales, Canberra (2009).
OGC: ITIL V3 Glossary of Terms and Definitions, v01, Office of Government Commerce (now UK Cabinet Office) (2007).
Principia Cybernetica: Principle of Suboptimization: http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/ASC/PRINCI_SUBOP.html, cited January 30, 2012.
E. Proper, D. Greefhorst: The Roles of Principles in Enterprise Architecture, Trends in Enterprise Architecture Research, Vol. 70, Springer Berlin Heidelberg, pp.57-70 (2010).
L. Skyttner: General Systems Theory: Problems, Perspectives, Practice, World Scientific Pub Co Inc, Singapore (2005).
J. Schekkerman: Enterprise Architecture: Good Practices Guide: How to Manage the Enterprise Architecture Practice, Trafford (2008).
D. Stelzer: Enterprise Architecture Principles: Literature Review and Research Directions, in Service-Oriented Computing, ICSOC/ServiceWave 2009 Workshops, Vol. 6275, A. Dan et al., Eds., Ed: Springer Berlin/Heidelberg, pp.12-21 (2010).
The Open Group: TOGAF®: www.opengroup.org/togaf. N. Wiener: Cybernetics, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1948).
Journal of Enterprise Architecture